Native Advertising's Murky Definition

Rebecca Lieb's picture

While working toward a definition of what native advertising is, it is equally important to focus on what native advertising is not.

The native part of native advertising is muddy — more on that in a moment. The advertising part is crystal clear. Advertising has always meant renting either time or space from a media company for a commercial message.

Time or space? The time part generally boils down to 15, 30, or 60 seconds (the most common units) from a broadcaster. The space part entails a square, rectangle, or an IAB unit, usually from a publisher — there are out-of-home opportunities for this as well. Advertising, simply, is renting time or space.

It was interesting, therefore, to attend a native advertising symposium as part of New York’s Internet Week and to find that at least half the sessions contained the term “content marketing.” Social media was discussed. Content marketing was discussed. But advertising — the renting time or space part — was hardly mentioned.

I’m willing to accept that content marketing is an enormous component of native advertising. Yet by definition, content marketing is not the advertising part of native advertising.  Here’s a variant definition of content marketing from my latest research report that I published on the subject:

“Content” is owned media created by the brand and published or distributed on media channels the brand controls. Content marketing is the practice of creating and publishing in owned media channels, as opposed to advertising, for which media is always rented time or space. A radical shift in marketing budgets is occurring as companies shift spend from a legacy focus on advertising to investments in content. The trend is toward “pull” rather than “push” marketing and has been greatly accelerated by an explosion of owned media channels — both those “fully owned” (e.g., websites and blogs) and social media channels in which brands largely control their presence and must continually feed with fresh content.

Content marketing, by definition, isn’t advertising. It’s owned media, not rented media. Native advertising, while difficult to differentiate semantically from banded, sponsored, or advertorial content, is a form of a union of paid advertising and owned content.

Where does the rubber hit the road? Disclosure.

Talk about meta: This recent article in The Guardian about content marketing appears to actually be native advertising. Or perhaps branded, sponsored, or advertorial content. It’s hard to say because there is zero information regarding whether or not money changed hands.

Here’s the entirety of the disclosure:

Jonny Rose is product evangelist for idio. The copy on this page is provided by Jugglit, sponsors of the digital entertainment hub.

Did Jugglit pay for this piece or provide free copy? Clearly it sponsors something else — is this entertainment hub part of The Guardian? What is idio’s role in this possible transaction?

I want to know. Don’t you?

The post originally published on iMedia Connection

Comments

Where Does The Content Budget Come From?'s picture

[...] we’re conducting research on native advertising. In working to define a very murky term, something is becoming crystal clear. Native advertising is a form of converged media: owned media [...]

Where Does The Content Budget Come From? ,Vancouver Island, 's picture

[...] we’re conducting investigate on local advertising. In operative to conclude a unequivocally ghastly term, something is apropos transparent clear. Native promotion is a form of converged media: owned media [...]

Where Does The Content Budget Come From? « TLC Niche Ma's picture

[…] we’re conducting research on native advertising. In working to define a very murky term, something is becoming crystal clear. Native advertising is a form of converged media: owned media […]

What Is Content Marketing? 7 Definitions | Teresita Gesell's picture

[…] content marketing and paid advertising, given the rise of native advertising. More recently, she wrote about content marketing’s role in native […]

Rebecca Lieb's picture

Thanks for asking, James. I tweet most of my posts from @lieblink

James Sullivan @ Advertising.com's picture

Hey, I see you have a twitter account, do you tweet all your new posts?

Add new comment

Filtered HTML

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd><pre>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

Rebecca Lieb

Rebecca Lieb is a strategic advisor, consultant, research analyst, keynote speaker, author, and columnist.

SEE MORE

Get in touch